We had the most amazing time at Captain's Beach House. The house was super clean and you could see Lake Superior from each room. The space was perfect for a couple (and our dog). It was decorated very cute and had all the major things we needed (grill, fridge/freezer, shower, etc.) plus some added comforts.
The best part, though, was of course the beach. Being just steps away from Lake Superior can't be beat and it was almost like having a private beach. The rock hunting was incredible (note: water shoes might be nice for swimming - as the rock hunting continues a little ways into the lake). We also completed a hike without having to drive anywhere.
The owner, Elyse, was very responsive and incredibly kind. All the people we met were also amazing. Could not have been a better trip and we look forward to hopefully returning soon.