Pros: The neighborhood and location are wonderful. We enjoyed live music, a craft fair, and the splash pad at the park, conveniently located directly behind the house during our stay. There were 3 Beach access paths, all within one block of the house, and that was a really nice feature. A grocery store, gift shop, Dole Whip stand, and pizza place are all within walking distance. The back yard is perfect for grilling. The fenced in area is small, but perfect for one or two dogs to play and do their business. (Sidenote: the back yard is covered in these tiny yellow flowers that pop opening bloom as the sun sets!) The bedrooms were decently large and sufficient in furnishings. Lots of drawers and closet space. The larger bathroom is very nice and accurate to the listed description.
Cons: The smaller bathroom had a very rough looking bathtub with a lot of stains. We arrived to the last tenants bag of dirty linens on the screened in porch. This bag sat there the entire duration of our stay, which was kinda gross. We found underwear in the dresser drawers in one bedroom and in another we found glass bottles and dirty clothes under the bed. Many of the throw pillows have mildew, especially on the screened porch. The game room is an old, uninsulated porch and becomes very hot for whoever is sleeping in the twin bed. Dirty dishes were still in the dishwasher upon our arrival. One giant roach crawled from under the sofa and terrified our kids but I get that when people run in and out of the house and this could allow insects in and understand. Only one bath towel and one washcloth per person is provided, so I recommend bringing your own bath linens should you need more. Electrical outlets are limited in number in many rooms. So, if you have a lot of devices that need charged or plugged in be aware. The screened porch could definitely use some love and finesse, there is visual damage to the ceiling and the deck and wooden boundary are very rough. We had 3 splinters in the kids feet during our 7 day stay. The view to the ocean is obstructed by newly constructed houses, but there is a beach access directly across the street. Please do watch out for the ant hills in the driveway and back yard, they do bite! The west side neighboring house is quite an eyesore. It has been severly damaged and has broken windows, busted in doors, and an overgrown lot.
If I were to rate this on a 1-10 scale with 10 being my dream rental I'd give this a 4.25.